As the class is well under way and we are almost at the half way point in the semester, I wanted to take a few moments to reflect upon the format of the class. As most of us can agree on the first day we were all quite confused, but I find it amazing how far we have gotten and the direction we have moved in. With the exception of Professor Dean's underlying expectations, the class has been entirely in our hands. Considering this is the first time for the course offering, there is even more control on behalf of the students. I have been thinking lately of the self-assessment and assessing of our fellow students. From my experience so far, you literally get out what you put into this class and it is fair to say a good chunk of my classmates are doing that. At this juncture it would be wise for everyone to make their own mid-term assessment of their progress and that of their classmates. This would make it easier to provide a final assessment.
In terms of the actual structure of the class, I feel time has been spent wisely during class. Coming from the perspective of someone who does not speak up often in class, I find it rewarding to listen to the opinions of others. The big discussions and small group discussions have both been beneficial in their own ways. I cannot speak on behalf of everyone, but I learn best in a flexible and changing environment. An environment this is not set in stone and leaves room for adjustment.
Monday, September 29, 2008
ispy Wrap Up (part 2)
When reflecting back upon Andrejevic's work and what I have been able to pull from it, I feel much more grounded and informed about what technology is capable of. More importantly, I am aware of the government's and other agency's abilities to surveil and monitor the general public. From the very beginning, we learn the price we pay when utilizing the internet. Not just in terms of an advertising aspect, but as well as personal information being datamined. Throughout our class discussions, we debated the concept of our info being collected and stored for various purposes. A small minority did not have any oppositions to this and most did have some legitimate concerns. The act of collecting data is controversial from the start, but who is to prevent you from viewing it. That seemed to have struck the nerve of most in that we have no capabilities of at least viewing the info stored. I had mentioned it earlier that some people should attempt to make it their initiative of trying to overcome this obstacle. Whether that be drafting a petition to the government or appropriate companies that perform this operation. Out of all the issues Andrejevic addresses, this topic seemed to have the biggest affect on my learning experience.
Clearly Andrejevic has his opinions and bias of what he is presenting, but as a class we were able to read through the text and devise our own arguments. ispy has by far been the most eye opening book that I have read. I look forward to the ensuing texts and publications we will be reading.
Clearly Andrejevic has his opinions and bias of what he is presenting, but as a class we were able to read through the text and devise our own arguments. ispy has by far been the most eye opening book that I have read. I look forward to the ensuing texts and publications we will be reading.
Thursday, September 25, 2008
ispy Wrap Up
Andrejevic wraps up the final few chapters with several key points as well as a summation of previous chapters. Along the lines of virtual communication, Andrejevic discusses social networks and the world of online dating. Social networks such as facebook, myspace, friendster, etc. all allow for social interaction. They are simply platforms in which people can customize their own user profile as they wish. With more than 100 million active users, Facebook is the 4th most trafficked website in the world and the most trafficked social media site in the world. The fastest growing demographic that utilize this service is 25 years old and older.
There are countless services for online dating. Imagine the convenience of not having to leave the privacy of your home when looking for a companion. All done behind a screen, someone can set up a match.com user account and begin the search. Not just match.com, but others such as eharmony, jdate, search your love, yahoo, etc. all serve the same purpose. People looking for other people and in most cases desiring some form of a relationship. How do you know if someone is being truthful or not? People commonly misrepresent themselves. There are certain services that will offer complete background checks on the individuals you are inquiring. Even with this added safety feature, there are still many holes within the system. Unfortunately this leads to much frustration on behalf of the user who is misrepresented.
This segways into another realm of surveillance. The ability to google or research information regarding a certain someone can very easily be done. As Andrejevic addresses background verification... is it right for people to have access to a background history or possibly criminal history of someone else? Lateral surveillance or peer-to-peer monitoring encompasses romantic interests, family, and friends or acquaintances. This type of surveillance is engaged via google, cameras, lie detectors, cell phones, and instant messages. Has this gone too far? Is it appropriate to be keeping track of friends like this. Does that represent the qualities of a true friend? This peer-to-peer monitoring is done indirectly and appears to be second nature for most people. Constantly text messaging on the cell phone, checking email all the time, and facebook are prime examples. It will simply become more and more difficult to put a hamper upon this form of surveillance as technology will only continue to grow.
There are countless services for online dating. Imagine the convenience of not having to leave the privacy of your home when looking for a companion. All done behind a screen, someone can set up a match.com user account and begin the search. Not just match.com, but others such as eharmony, jdate, search your love, yahoo, etc. all serve the same purpose. People looking for other people and in most cases desiring some form of a relationship. How do you know if someone is being truthful or not? People commonly misrepresent themselves. There are certain services that will offer complete background checks on the individuals you are inquiring. Even with this added safety feature, there are still many holes within the system. Unfortunately this leads to much frustration on behalf of the user who is misrepresented.
This segways into another realm of surveillance. The ability to google or research information regarding a certain someone can very easily be done. As Andrejevic addresses background verification... is it right for people to have access to a background history or possibly criminal history of someone else? Lateral surveillance or peer-to-peer monitoring encompasses romantic interests, family, and friends or acquaintances. This type of surveillance is engaged via google, cameras, lie detectors, cell phones, and instant messages. Has this gone too far? Is it appropriate to be keeping track of friends like this. Does that represent the qualities of a true friend? This peer-to-peer monitoring is done indirectly and appears to be second nature for most people. Constantly text messaging on the cell phone, checking email all the time, and facebook are prime examples. It will simply become more and more difficult to put a hamper upon this form of surveillance as technology will only continue to grow.
Friday, September 19, 2008
HWS Monitoring
As I was looking through "this week in photos" on the HWS site, I was rather surprised to see a photo of myself. The fact that I was not asked to pose or given any clue about the photos being taken makes me a bit uncomfortable. It is not worth getting worked up over the photos that were taken of people without their knowledge, but it made me reflect back upon the relating class discussion. When one enrolls into a private institution do you then automatically forfeit all of your rights and privacy? The sad truth is it almost appears so. Not just with photos, but much more. Consider the party and social scene here... As the drinks are being circulated and the noise level escalates on a Friday or Saturday night in the dorm room, the first concern is campus security. Then security knocks on the door, looks around and then either gives a warning or writes everyone up. This is actually the good scenario to get caught in because security does not have to make a courtesy knock at all. They have the ability to key themselves into any and every room if there is reasonable suspicion and cause. After all they are campus security and tasked with the job of protecting the students, right?? We are all considered adults or young adults and fork over quite a lot of tuition money, so should we be given more respect, rights, and freedoms??
The Google Revolution!
As I read through chapter four, Icommerce of Ispy, I was intrigued by the detail noted on what Google's agenda is. As we discussed in class and up until recently I was not aware that google had the ability to sift through email exchanges in order to personalize their advertisements. Maybe I did not thoroughly read through the agreement when signing up for my gmail account or for that matter, does anyone actually read those agreements word for word. Andrejevic specifically discusses how the info is obtained and who is doing the obtaining. As google states, it is a computer generated system that scans though emails and not a human effort. I guess this is the part that is suppose to make the concerned consumer feel better. However should that really make you more comfortable? What is that to say about any other personal exchanges over the internet? Just because it is a computer to computer monitoring system does not fully justify the actions. Maybe I should read the AOL email agreement more carefully now that I know googles.
Thursday, September 18, 2008
Class Discussion - Live!
A lot of good thoughts and opinions circulating. One that has struck me the most is when Tom addressed the issue of comparing the shopping experience of online and offline. He characterizes the WWW as a public domain so in that perspective, is it really fair to have something monitored or private??
You have a choice of what you put on the internet. If you are concerned with your privacy then do not take the traditional route of trying to obtain something via the internet. "Digital enclosure" means privatization of information. This is a direct correlation to the point Mark Andrejevic is making.
Is it crossing the line when your email exchanges and cell phone conversations are being monitored without your knowledge?
You have a choice of what you put on the internet. If you are concerned with your privacy then do not take the traditional route of trying to obtain something via the internet. "Digital enclosure" means privatization of information. This is a direct correlation to the point Mark Andrejevic is making.
Is it crossing the line when your email exchanges and cell phone conversations are being monitored without your knowledge?
Tuesday, September 16, 2008
Response of Class Discussion 9/16/08
I found today's agenda rewarding and useful! As each class goes by, I feel much more grounded and confident with my posts. There was a lot of good discussion today going back and forth. Several key topics were addressed that Andrejevic highlights throughout his book.
The issue of data mining and the concept of third party companies actually storing personal information about consumers still makes me a bit nervous. Like most of my class mates I do not have anything to hide, but would feel comfortable it I had the ability to obtain the records or at least view what is kept in the deep dark virtual memory banks. It should not even be a question of who has the right. It is controversial from the start for information to be collected in that manner and to be denied access is unacceptable. It is as if we are all being exploited for being private citizens that happen to live lives. For every bit of info collecting upon us, we should receive a cut back or royalty. As the expression, "time is money" is nothing new then our time is clearly being taken advantage of. Unfortunately the money hungry and technocraized society we live in does not allow room for that.
I eagerly await next classes discussion! Allowing us to teach each other will move complete responsibility and accountability upon our half.
The issue of data mining and the concept of third party companies actually storing personal information about consumers still makes me a bit nervous. Like most of my class mates I do not have anything to hide, but would feel comfortable it I had the ability to obtain the records or at least view what is kept in the deep dark virtual memory banks. It should not even be a question of who has the right. It is controversial from the start for information to be collected in that manner and to be denied access is unacceptable. It is as if we are all being exploited for being private citizens that happen to live lives. For every bit of info collecting upon us, we should receive a cut back or royalty. As the expression, "time is money" is nothing new then our time is clearly being taken advantage of. Unfortunately the money hungry and technocraized society we live in does not allow room for that.
I eagerly await next classes discussion! Allowing us to teach each other will move complete responsibility and accountability upon our half.
Monday, September 15, 2008
Assignment 4
In response to the first three chapters of Mark Andrejevic's "iSpy," I find myself caught off guard in regards to the reality of the amount of privacy one has when touring around in cyberspace. Andrejevic's example of the digital enclosure states that it is "the creation of an interactive realm wherein every action and transaction generates information about itself" (pg. 2). Interactivity referring to the notion of IPolitics, ICulture, and ICentury is the revolution of customization. For example, Nike's campaign allowed anyone to call in and customize a pair of shoes for a flat rate of $99 with a visual of it on a times square billboard. This literally gave the consumer the empowerment and control over their purchase to the most extreme degree.
The question of how much privacy do you really have is at hand. Has society gone too far? It is the ability to have total convenience and customization for a trade of privacy that is occurring. Not just Nike, but even the regular department store or Bannana Republic you choose to shop in. They all have the ability to tailor your shopping experience by a track record and purchase history. The information gathered is commonly sold to a third party for the purpose of being organized and archived. Therefore there is a constant demand for new consumer information. Walmart is a perfect example of a global enterprise that has grasped its tentacles around the consumer. With there headquarters based in Bentonville, Arkansas, they control all the operations of every store and truck that is transporting product. Their control even goes down to changing the temperature gauge in a store if necessary.
Facebook has proven to be a success as well in the advertising sector. Based upon the user's profile settings they are able to target specific ads of interest. Granted not all of the ads are really something of interest to the user and in many cases they are either hit or miss. Andrejevic addresses the lady who started to receive coupons in the mail for diapers after being pregnant for a period of time. This is just one story and not that uncommon.
In terms of technology monitoring, GPS systems and other tracking devices can be installed in cell phones and under the hood of a vehicle. This is designed for parents to keep a close eye on their children. With a chip in the phone, an on demand location can always be determined so you will virtually never be out of sight. Tracking devices within the vehicle allow as well for a location and additional info such as the speed the car is traveling at. It is hard to believe, but yes your parents can possibly know if you are speeding. These technologies help to cultivate the argument of whether it has gone too far or is it necessary for safety. There are the confirmed benefits associated with safety and an over all peace of mind for the parent. I would personally be opposed to having any sort of device monitoring my life. It is way to voyeuristic and people are granted the right to their freedoms and independence.
This is just the tip of the ice berg as society may very well be governed completely by computers and the machine at a certain point in time!
The question of how much privacy do you really have is at hand. Has society gone too far? It is the ability to have total convenience and customization for a trade of privacy that is occurring. Not just Nike, but even the regular department store or Bannana Republic you choose to shop in. They all have the ability to tailor your shopping experience by a track record and purchase history. The information gathered is commonly sold to a third party for the purpose of being organized and archived. Therefore there is a constant demand for new consumer information. Walmart is a perfect example of a global enterprise that has grasped its tentacles around the consumer. With there headquarters based in Bentonville, Arkansas, they control all the operations of every store and truck that is transporting product. Their control even goes down to changing the temperature gauge in a store if necessary.
Facebook has proven to be a success as well in the advertising sector. Based upon the user's profile settings they are able to target specific ads of interest. Granted not all of the ads are really something of interest to the user and in many cases they are either hit or miss. Andrejevic addresses the lady who started to receive coupons in the mail for diapers after being pregnant for a period of time. This is just one story and not that uncommon.
In terms of technology monitoring, GPS systems and other tracking devices can be installed in cell phones and under the hood of a vehicle. This is designed for parents to keep a close eye on their children. With a chip in the phone, an on demand location can always be determined so you will virtually never be out of sight. Tracking devices within the vehicle allow as well for a location and additional info such as the speed the car is traveling at. It is hard to believe, but yes your parents can possibly know if you are speeding. These technologies help to cultivate the argument of whether it has gone too far or is it necessary for safety. There are the confirmed benefits associated with safety and an over all peace of mind for the parent. I would personally be opposed to having any sort of device monitoring my life. It is way to voyeuristic and people are granted the right to their freedoms and independence.
This is just the tip of the ice berg as society may very well be governed completely by computers and the machine at a certain point in time!
Thursday, September 11, 2008
Group Project
Based upon the discussions we had in Tuesday's class... I think there is a lot of potential for a group project on the topic of campaigns and elections. Would anyone else be interested in something along these lines?
Assignment 3
In response to the articles we were assigned and specifically Jodi Dean's "Blogging Theory" and Mattathias Schwartz's "The Trolls Among Us," there is much up for discussion. As Jodi breaks down the theory behind blogging and some of her own personal experience, the amount of risk is apparent. For example she addresses her initial experience when a particular neo-nazi group took offense to her comments and made that clear with their response. It is very much the price you pay when entering the blogging world or any similar platform. One must always be conscious of trying to conceal their identity when communicating with strangers. Quite frankly you may never really know who the other person is behind the screen. As Jodi notes a comment by Chris Robinson, "a kind of two-way voyeurism. I see into the lived life of others; and, in response, I reveal and surprise myself." As Robinson feels, it is as if someone were peering into the life of someone else without permission.
Jodi addresses the affects blogging has upon the academic realm, specifically that of a university professor. Is your integrity and professionalism tarnished by expressing freedom of speech through various modes of communication? A large contingent of academics feel that is true and describe it is black and white. In their mind there is no middle ground or grey area. However that does not put a hamper upon Jodi's ability and many others to express their feelings. Unfortunately there is nothing to prevent the malicious uncalled for attacks by bloggers that occur on a daily basis.
Another aspect of blogging and the internet community as a whole is the idea of trolling. As Schwartz says, "internet users adopted the word 'troll' to denote someone who intentionally disrupts online communities" (pg. 1). The concept behind trolling is to lure online users out by asking rhetorical or "stupid" questions as bait. As you would feel the average person knows better than to fall for a trap, but a lot of these traps are masked in a deceptive manner. Further more as trollers establish a line of communication with someone else, they can then syphon personal information from them. It is as if they are strictly using them for their own self interest and then discard when done. This sly technique is nothing new to the online world, but must be taken into serious consideration. Innocent lives are at stake especially when we here accounts of young teenage girls taking their own lives because they were in love with someone who really wasn't who they said they were.
Cyberspace can be a scary world and people should be taking necessary precautions. Virtually anything and everything can be retraced on the internet. Even from the simple instant messages you exchange with a friend or the facebook photos you choose not to share. That is why there is a huge emphasis upon security and authentication throughout the corporate sector. Companies, institutions, and banks are not in the position to take hits that damage their privacy and security. As we used to say "looks can be deceiving," well "screens can be deceiving" as well. Who knows where the future will take us and how safe we will be. Will the united states reach a point where the internet is maintained and monitored by the government on a very close level? Will certain websites be banned? Time will tell.
Jodi addresses the affects blogging has upon the academic realm, specifically that of a university professor. Is your integrity and professionalism tarnished by expressing freedom of speech through various modes of communication? A large contingent of academics feel that is true and describe it is black and white. In their mind there is no middle ground or grey area. However that does not put a hamper upon Jodi's ability and many others to express their feelings. Unfortunately there is nothing to prevent the malicious uncalled for attacks by bloggers that occur on a daily basis.
Another aspect of blogging and the internet community as a whole is the idea of trolling. As Schwartz says, "internet users adopted the word 'troll' to denote someone who intentionally disrupts online communities" (pg. 1). The concept behind trolling is to lure online users out by asking rhetorical or "stupid" questions as bait. As you would feel the average person knows better than to fall for a trap, but a lot of these traps are masked in a deceptive manner. Further more as trollers establish a line of communication with someone else, they can then syphon personal information from them. It is as if they are strictly using them for their own self interest and then discard when done. This sly technique is nothing new to the online world, but must be taken into serious consideration. Innocent lives are at stake especially when we here accounts of young teenage girls taking their own lives because they were in love with someone who really wasn't who they said they were.
Cyberspace can be a scary world and people should be taking necessary precautions. Virtually anything and everything can be retraced on the internet. Even from the simple instant messages you exchange with a friend or the facebook photos you choose not to share. That is why there is a huge emphasis upon security and authentication throughout the corporate sector. Companies, institutions, and banks are not in the position to take hits that damage their privacy and security. As we used to say "looks can be deceiving," well "screens can be deceiving" as well. Who knows where the future will take us and how safe we will be. Will the united states reach a point where the internet is maintained and monitored by the government on a very close level? Will certain websites be banned? Time will tell.
Monday, September 8, 2008
Assignment 2
The question of technology and how it has shaped us or whether we shape technology and the future of it is the main question at hand. Technology and the evolution of new media has greatly influenced society and culture. To feed off of the comical you tube clip, the two philosopher like men clearly resemble a direction that society has already entered and will continue in the direction. This accurate depiction is quite alarming for the future generations to come. In many cases we get so accustomed to what we are used to, like in the video clip when the gentleman needs to be instructed on how to open a book. From that point it is an enormous step to adapt and learn a new technique.
In today's world, technology has grasped its tentacles around us that it is impossible to escape. We are surrounded by technology inside and outside of the classroom. This particular class "Politics of the Internet" is a perfect example. To even start with the basics from books and pencils, those are examples of the rudimentary forms of technology that we are so accustomed to. Dennis Baron's "From Pencils to Pixels: The Stages of Literacy Technologies" helps to evaluate the various forms of literacy technology. In other words the ways of manipulating text. From the days of the telegraph, that initially was a very much advanced form of communication. From that point technology has transcended greatly throughout the generations as we blog from state of the art computers now. Will there ever be a cap or culmination of all the world's technology? It is hard to know whether we will outlive technology or will it outlive us? At this rate it appears to be outliving us.
As we try to mold our lives based upon new innovations, the reverse effect is happening as well. Paul Levinson's "Digital McLuhan" provides an excellent account of how Marshall McLuhan's work and ideas in combination of Levinson's interpretation have affected society. McLuhan's early thoughts and ideas were commonly discredited because of his lack of support and generalizations. However is insight into where technology was heading is quite fascinating to analyze after the fact. His several works and publications have now gained much recognition for the contributions it has had on the tech boom beginning in the 1980s. McLuhan used his witty metaphors such as the "global village" and "acoustic space." The global village theory allows the village to be a haven of not just the audience, but interaction among the audience. This fast tracks the process to the age of Internet and the "online villager."
The medium or the mode of communication dates back to the transistor radio and first television sets. New Media depends on innovations and the advance of technology. The concept of orality is important to consider as well. How do we process and receive information? How much longer will people or authors for that matter take any time to draft out a publication when it can all be done at the finger tips. This big question will be very interesting to see where it takes us or where the future will take us. At some point life may be completely automated and digitized without having to lift a finger. Almost scary in some respects to think about it!
Back to our first assignment, how does this affect the most basic form of human interaction of being speech. Will "face to face" time even be necessary at all when conducting business? Does that mean people will all be living sedentary lifestyles in which they do not need to leave the privacy of their own homes. I invite any responses and look forward to what others have to say!
Wednesday, September 3, 2008
Assignment 1
As a third year Hobart student the first day of Professor's Dean's class was quite different from what I have experienced before. Never have I been confronted with the scenario of having a class with no professor present and not receiving any prior knowledge of this. It is fair to say that this caught the entire class off guard creating a layer of chaos and confusion. As some of my fellow students address, anyone could have gotten up and left at any moment. Instead people decided to stick it out with their attention focused on the one student who took the initiative of loading the blog on the screen. If nobody had taken the initiative, then I feel it would have been likely to see people leaving.
This became a challenging task for the students to stay in the classroom despite the fact that there was no professor present. I imagine as we will discuss in Thursday's class, this scenario poses the question and value of "face to face" contact. How important is "face to face" contact? As we clearly noticed, having a figure head or someone in charge provides that extra cushion to remain comfortable. It is the organization and structure that 95% of Hobart students are bred to abide by from a young age that makes them feel comfortable and reduces the anxiety level. Yes the media and technology is constantly revolving around us with various forms of communication, but when it comes to education, nobody knows anything different then the "face to face" relationship.
If I were to use the corporate and business world as an example, think about all the personal face to face relationships that are developed and necessary for success. How do you expect to apply and interview for a financial institution if there is no actual face time? In today's world business is conducted on all sorts of levels including video conferences, but nothing can replace the physical interaction between two or more humans present.
It is possible for future generations to come that physical human interaction will be completely eradicated at some point. I do not foresee this happening any time soon though.
This became a challenging task for the students to stay in the classroom despite the fact that there was no professor present. I imagine as we will discuss in Thursday's class, this scenario poses the question and value of "face to face" contact. How important is "face to face" contact? As we clearly noticed, having a figure head or someone in charge provides that extra cushion to remain comfortable. It is the organization and structure that 95% of Hobart students are bred to abide by from a young age that makes them feel comfortable and reduces the anxiety level. Yes the media and technology is constantly revolving around us with various forms of communication, but when it comes to education, nobody knows anything different then the "face to face" relationship.
If I were to use the corporate and business world as an example, think about all the personal face to face relationships that are developed and necessary for success. How do you expect to apply and interview for a financial institution if there is no actual face time? In today's world business is conducted on all sorts of levels including video conferences, but nothing can replace the physical interaction between two or more humans present.
It is possible for future generations to come that physical human interaction will be completely eradicated at some point. I do not foresee this happening any time soon though.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)